Employee's Failure to Return Supervisor's Phone Calls Dooms FMLA Claim

When an employee's request for medical leave is vague or is unclear, the Family and Medical Leave Act regulations specifically allow (in fact, they require) the employer to question the employee further to determine whether the absence potentially qualifies under the FMLA.  When the employee fails to respond to these reasonable inquiries, the employee may lose the right to FMLA protection. 

Such was the case for Robert Righi.  In a fantastic opinion for employers, a federal appellate court recently upheld the dismissal of Mr. Righi's FMLA claim because he failed to respond to his supervisor's telephone calls inquiring about his need for a leave of absence.  Righi v. SMC Corporation of America

The Facts

Righi, a salesman for SMC Corp., was the primary caretaker for his mother, who regularly suffered complications from diabetes.  As a result, Righi often took FMLA leave to care for her.  On the occasion at issue, however, he asked for time off after his mother accidentally overdosed on her medication. 

Continue Reading

Failure to Follow Employer's Leave Procedures Dooms FMLA Claim

Employers frustrated with their employees' lack of communication during FMLA leave have found a friend in the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals.  In what must be described as a solid win for employers, the appellate court (which covers IL, IN and WI) affirmed the dismissal of a former employee's Family and Medical Leave Act claim against the company that fired her after she failed to provide proper notice under the company's policies for an extension of leave.  Brown v. Automotive Components Holdings, LLC, and Ford Motor Co.

Continue Reading

FMLA Poster In Other Languages?

In a recent post we reviewed the rules relating to posting and publishing the DOL's "General Notice" poster. Among other things, the FMLA rules require employers who have a significant number of employees who do not read English to publish the notice in a language in which the employees are literate. The DOL has a version of the poster available in Spanish, but (as I confirmed with a call to the Department today) not other languages. To make matters more difficult, so far I have not been able to find a vendor who can provide the poster in any other language. 

So, I throw the question out to you: do you know of a vendor or other source where employers can obtain the FMLA poster in a language other than Spanish or English? If so, please share in the comments. 

An Employee Has Requested FMLA Leave. Now What Do I Do? - Podcast No. 14

“Notice of Eligibility?  Designation Notice?  Medical certification form?  I give up!”

We often hear from clients that they have a tough time properly responding to an employee’s request for leave that might be covered by the FMLA.  Clearly, under the new FMLA regulations, employers must be able to master this response.    

After listening to this month’s FMLA Insights podcast, employers will have a clear understanding of what their responsibilities are when responding to a request for leave.

During the podcast, we will reference the DOL’s model Notice of Eligibility and Rights and Responsibilities (WH-381) and Designation Notice (WH-382).

Employee's Headache No Excuse For Insubordination

pill bottle iStock_000000505895XSmall.jpg

Under the FMLA, an employer's obligation to provide leave arises only after an employee gives notice that he or she needs FMLA leave. However, it is well-established that an employee need not explicitly mention the FMLA when requesting leave. Rather, an employee's notice is sufficient if it gives the employer enough information to reasonably conclude that the employee may need leave for an FMLA-qualifying reason. Determining whether an employee's request for leave meets this requirement is a difficult proposition, particularly when the employee appears to be using the request to avoid instructions or shield himself from discipline. A recent decision of the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals sheds some light on the subject, and affirms that an employee cannot avoid discharge for insubordination merely by claiming that he had a headache and needed to go home. Gipson v. Vought Aircraft Industries, Inc. (.pdf).

Continue Reading

Cleaning Up Mom's Flooded Basement Not Protected by FMLA

Flood insurance pic.jpgFor employers, it pays to listen closely to the reason for which an employee requests time off, since the reason may not always be covered by the FMLA.  Kind of like occasions when the employee tells you he needs time off to clean his mother's flooded basement.

Take Joe Lane, a medical technologist for Pontiac Osteopathic Hospital.  Joe, who lived with his mother, sought and was granted FMLA intermittent FMLA leave for six months to care for his mom, who suffered from diabetes, high blood pressure, weight loss and arthritis.  He needed leave from time to time to provide her food and transport her to doctors' appointments, which he did without issue for the next four months.

For Joe, when it rains, it pours.  Literally.  Right into his mother's basement.  Joe was absent for four consecutive days and, in violation of the Hospital's personnel policies, he failed to call in his absences.  Thereafter, he informed the Hospital that he would need additional time off to clean up flooding in his mom's basement.  He claimed that the "flood cleaning days" should be excused because his mother had hepatitis and the stagnant water was a "breeding ground" for the disease.  The Hospital disagreed and fired him.

At that moment, Joe's FMLA claims went down the drain. 

Continue Reading